The Secret to a Better Manuscript

Greetings!

Did you do it? Were you able to find a critique group? Or did you get super brave, meet other writers, and start your own group? That is an option and certainly has its advantages. No matter how it happened, you are about to discover the secret to a better manuscript.

Guidelines are Key

The best writing critique groups have guidelines. It's a must to keep the group running smoothly. Depending on how many members you have, some groups give each person a set amount of time for reading and receiving critiques. For larger groups, this works well. There are two types of guidelines: one for giving feedback, and one for receiving feedback. This week, we'll talk about giving feedback.

The Most Important Critiquing Rule

The number one rule for giving your fellow writers feedback is to always start with a positive. Think of it like a kindness sandwich: start with a positive, give constructive feedback, and end with a positive. Starting out with something that you liked, or something that worked for you, sets the tone for the rest of the critique. It's super important.

The Big Picture

In the beginning, it's good to focus on the big picture of a story when critiquing. Think about the characters. Were they well defined? How about the pacing and story structure? Did the story build up tension, and then descend with a satisfying resolution? Unless the writer asks for specifics to look and listen for, this is a good way to start when you're giving feedback.

Always Use "I" Statements

When critiquing, "I" statements are easier for the writer to accept than "You" statements. Saying, "I got a little confused and lost during the part where . . ." sounds much better than, "What you wrote was confusing, and you completely lost me."

Think Like the Writer

Receiving critiques can be emotionally challenging. Remember: always be kind and respectful when giving your input. Because you are a writer as well, you may be tempted to rewrite parts of their manuscript. Please don't do this. Give suggestions. Remember that the writer has worked hard to make this manuscript their best. Their heart and soul went into it. They have their favorite parts. Putting yourself in their place with help both you and them.

Your Turn Next!

You will be up next to read your manuscript and receive critiques. Take a deep breath! You've got this. Next week, I will put you in the reading seat, and show you how to make that seat much more comfortable. 🙂